Welcome to Noodle Pudding
Noodle Pudding, a cozy Italian gem in Brooklyn, offers a memorable dining experience. From the welcoming staff to the delicious homemade dishes, every detail is crafted with love. The menu boasts classic Italian fare with fresh pasta and flavorful seafood options. Don't miss out on the savory octopus carpaccio, garlic bread with chili oil, and mouthwatering pappardelle with mushrooms and spinach. The intimate ambiance and attentive service make it perfect for date nights or special occasions. While the cash-only policy may catch you off guard, the exceptional food and charming atmosphere make it well worth a visit.
- 38 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States38 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States Hotline: +1 718-625-3737
Welcome to Noodle Pudding, a charming Italian restaurant located in Brooklyn, NY. Known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious homemade dishes, Noodle Pudding offers a wide range of options for both vegetarians and meat lovers alike.
Customers rave about the fresh pasta, savory starters, and delectable desserts at Noodle Pudding. From mouthwatering octopus carpaccio to hearty pappardelle with mushrooms and spinach, every dish is made with love and attention to detail.
One standout feature of Noodle Pudding is its cash-only policy, adding to the old-school charm of the restaurant. The attentive staff, romantic ambiance, and excellent wine selection make dining at Noodle Pudding a truly memorable experience.
Whether you're looking for a cozy date night spot or a place to impress out-of-towners, Noodle Pudding offers the perfect setting for any occasion. Be sure to try their famous garlic bread, calamari, and tagliatelle for a truly unforgettable dining experience.
With its gender-neutral restrooms, outdoor seating, and friendly service, Noodle Pudding has something for everyone. Don't miss out on the opportunity to savor the flavors of Italy at this hidden gem in Brooklyn.

Great food and one of the best in New York! Really a pleasure Try their starters with beets and also their Burrata salad etc and days fish .. so delicious all of it and staff are awesome

We loved our server Heather and seating outside to watch passersby and restaurant activity. Cocktails were great prices and there's a $5 house wine! We had calamari which was great and caco Pepe with the egg and zucchini and then rigatoni. All yummy and great ambiance. Love coming about Tuesday night yoga in Brooklyn bridge park as a romantic way to spend a Tuesday. Cash only , don't get caught with all the fees at nearby ATM! We had to go back twice so we had enough for tip

We were in town for a conference and were told to go here by a local, and it did not disappoint! The ambiance was old school Italian vibe with a home-y feel. The staff were all super welcoming and informative. We ordered wine and an aperol spritz, and both were great. We also got the garlic bread, and I highly recommend. I ordered the lasagna and it was HUGE. Everything we tried was delicious, and you could tell the pasta was fresh. We got in with no wait, but it's a smaller place so you might need to wait if you have a bigger party! Also it is CASH ONLY so know that before going!!

**CASH ONLY** The food was so delicious! We ordered octopus carpaccio, garlic bread with homemade chili oil and olives for appetizers. The olives were soaked in fragrant extra virgin olive oil. The octopus was savory and topped with chopped pistachio. I ordered the pappardelle with mushroom, spinach and a generous amount of parmesan for my entree. We ended the night with tiramisu that melted in your mouth. The staff was very friendly but service was on the slower side because of how busy the restaurant was on a Thursday night. We tried a few times to flag down the waiter. They turn off the music and sing happy birthday to the tables that were celebrating. Everyone in the restaurant participated and the moments were adorable.

Every Single dish is Perfect!!! Home made & made with love!!!!!! Staff in front are perfect!!! Owner is a True Gem and the Best Cook Ever!!! I come from Brooklyn and am Italian, I know Perfection when I taste it!! Toto, Anthony & staff are all Perfect!!!! Not one dish will disappoint !! Delicious!!!! Best place Ever!!!!

Food is pretty good but definitely for the price point ... like average $30 per plate ... The atmosphere is really cozy and it's hormonal inside when it's cold outside. The bathrooms are very clean and very adorable.

Great pasta spot that makes you feel like you're in Italy. Lots of options here, including rotating specials so there's something for everyone! Food: We ordered family style and split the garlic bread, calamari, bucatini and linguine. I highly recommend the garlic bread -- it was a great starter and convinced me to purchase their in-house Calabrian chili oil. The calamari was also lightly fried and not too oily, so it doesn't sit heavily. Service: the hostess was incredibly sweet and sat everyone as quickly as possible. We went on a warm Saturday evening so the place was crowded, but she did a great job of seating everyone according to their preferences. Our waiter was also very engaging and checked in on us often. Insider tips: cash only! So be prepared for that. They also sell their Calabrian chili oil you can take home for $20. Good for: date nights, impressing out of towners. A more intimate setting so I don't recommend it as much for large groups.

This is a really intimate and cozy restaurant in Brooklyn for home style Italian food. This was our first time here and we were lucky enough to be seated next to the windows where we could watch everyone passing by on the sidewalk and had a good view of the restaurant. Service is a little slow so don't come here with the intention of leaving under an hour. Its a spot for good friends and conversation, definitely not for a quick bite or business meal. Please note that this restaurant is cash only. There is an ATM down the street at the convenience store if you forget on your way over (We may or may not know that fact because we forgot until we were a block away). Everything we had was fantastic and their wine selection was pretty good. Our favorite parts of the meal were definitely the main course. We highly recommend the tagliatelle. Super yummy and decent portion sizes.

Once again even after years, Noodle Pudding never disappoints. Get here early for a table with no wait and expect great service and delicious food at reasonable prices. $5 house wine. And it's good. Wonderful focaccia with soppresata and mozzarella. The bread is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Ask for a bit of olive oil!! Pastas all look good but we chose the salmon with escarole and beans (always my absolute favorite) and chicken scarpariello that was very good in a brown sauce with potatoes. Dessert was affogatto with a biscotti and what more could you want ? Cash only. And we'll be back.